Man, you’re not the only one. I have the same problem with the same reviewer. I understood that i have to do something on my file but the feedback of the reviewer was always contradictory.
My item is this one: http://graphicriver.net/forums/thread/strange-reasons-for-rejected-item/38213
I don’t know about you but i want to try again with my item. I will request another reviewer on my file because i think it’s a matter of tastes.
Don’t give up.
Closing this thread per anderworks’ request. Glad to hear we’ve helped get the situation resolved!