I’m afraid I have to agree to some extent.
Lack of browser “back” and “forward” navigation (and bookmarking) on full Flash sites that don’t implement deep linking is probably the biggest issue that users will have.
I found having 5 different places where user can have their say a bit of overkill: chat rooms, avatar chat, message board, guestbook AND a “comments” pop-out.
Also, at one point the “comments” pop-out came out over a gallery page with the “Add comment” and “Close comments” tabs missing, so it was impossible to close it without refreshing the site.
Found a couple of spelling mistakes: “Ready Comments” and “Avartar Chat”
Also: opening the “comments” pop-out turns off the music and closes the music player leaving no indication of which track was playing (why? Probably because the “X” (close) cursor is still active even when it is used to open the comments pop-out).
Also : the “Info” tab on the music player does nothing (on the tracks I tried) If there is no info there should be no tab (or something to indicate there is no info so it doesn’t just look like the tab is broken)
Also: the “X” cursor (to close music, images, etc) disappears behind the “Read Comments” tab when it slides out (should be on top and should change to hand cursor).
Also all the pages that open in new tabs (chat rooms, avatar chat, message board, guestbook and support) have a very inconsistent look and feel.
(Well, you did ask for opinions .. hope that’s not too critical for you 
)
Request processing...